Entertaining Chidambaram’s plea against remand orders will set bad precedent: CBI to SC

Questioning the order of the Supreme Court, the CBI has submitted to the apex court that such an order would set a very bad precedent

Questioning the order of the Supreme Court, the CBI has submitted to the apex court that such an order would set a very bad precedent
Questioning the order of the Supreme Court, the CBI has submitted to the apex court that such an order would set a very bad precedent

Raising a protest, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) told the Supreme Court (SC) Tuesday that entertaining former Finance Minister P Chidambaram‘s plea challenging the remand orders of a trial court would “set a very bad precedent”. The CBI sought dismissal of Chidambaram’s plea and said that similarly placed accused in trial courts all over the country would come directly to the apex court, challenging the remand orders of the trial court “as liberty of other citizens would not be less important than of petitioner (P Chidambaram)”.

The affidavit of CBI was filed before a bench of Justices R Banumathi and A S Bopanna, which directed (in an unprecedented way) that Chidambaram remain in the custody of the CBI till September 5 and listed his plea for hearing on Thursday – September 5. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, filed the affidavit on the plea of Chidambaram in which he has challenged the non-bailable warrant (NBW) issued against him and the subsequent remand orders passed by the trial court.

In an unprecedented way, the bench headed by Justice Banumati ordered that “status quo” be maintained on Chidambaram’s custody despite the CBI insisting that it does not require his further custodial interrogation in the case.

In an affidavit filed by CBI S P Rajpal Meena, the probe agency said: “I state and submit that entertaining of a petition under Article 136 of the Constitution directly against an order of remand passed by the competent court in exercise of discretionary jurisdiction under section 167 of the CrPC would set a very bad precedent.”

It said there is a remedy available against the orders before the higher forum and it is settled legal position that this court would not invoke its constitutional discretionary jurisdiction under Article

136, directly against an order of the Special Judge remanding an accused to a few days of police custody.

“If this court were to entertain the Special Leave Petition (SLP) directly against the order of the special judge remanding the accused to police custody, all the litigants whose prayer for listing of SLP against anticipatory bail are refused and are thereafter arrested will be entitled to file similar petitions challenging the orders of special judge granting police remand directly before this court as the personal liberty of other citizens (which is interfered with in accordance with law) would not be less important than petitioner,” the CBI said.

It said that normally such orders are not interfered with even by the high courts, more particularly when the Special Court has, after an elaborate and lengthy hearing, passed a detailed speaking order in exercise of its judicial discretion. Referring to a Constitution Bench verdict of apex court in 1986, the CBI said that normally the high court is the final arbiter in bail/ anticipatory bail matters.

“Generally all SLPs challenging the bail/ anticipatory bail are, therefore, not allowed to be listed immediately on mentioning before the Chief Justice of India unless extraordinary and special reasons are shown,” it said. The CBI further said that Chidambaram has not pointed out any extraordinary circumstances which would have justified any deviation from the consistent practice being followed.

 

“There are no extraordinary or grave circumstances which justifies the petitioner to by-pass the statutory remedies which are resorted to by all citizens challenging the order of remand and there may be no justification for allowing the petitioner to do so by entertaining the present SLP,” it said and sought dismissal of appeal filed by Chidambaram.

The apex court Bench headed by Justice Banumati is also scheduled to pronounce its order on September 5 on Chidambaram’s separate plea in which he has challenged the August 20 verdict of the Delhi High Court denying him anticipatory bail in the INX Media money laundering case lodged by the Enforcement Directorate.

Team PGurus

We are a team of focused individuals with expertise in at least one of the following fields viz. Journalism, Technology, Economics, Politics, Sports & Business. We are factual, accurate and unbiased.

31 COMMENTS

  1. I apologise for m inability to understand the bulk of the verbal diarrhea of most of the above Comments. Will someone kindly explain what the CBO submission means —in simple English. And kindly exclude the Hus and Has.

    Arvind Lavakare

  2. Economy SHD BE THE ONLY CONCERN…ECONOMY IS BELOW ZIMBABWE NOW, Under Italian Inquisition Raj, everybody in India was a billionare, unemployment was 0%, people were overemployed, fARMERS were NOT committing suicide, people Got 5 Star food provided at home by Govt of Italy, All Govt officers every day visited each and every home asking people “Bhai koi takleef to nahin” IN ITALIAN, ECONOMY WAS BOOMING AT 1 MILLION % AND WAS 1000 TIMES OF US..NOBODY WAS REQUIRED TO GO TO OFFICES, everybody was provided with a Huge AC bunglow with servants AND BMW Cars (sourced from Italy??) under Italian, PC Raj. free water, electricity, unlimited facilities, EVERBODY had a PVT JET
    SO Much SO that India had all the money to pay for Italian pigshit to be fed to PIDIS,till Dr RAJIV DICIT got it stopped and was subsequently murdered poisoned in LOVE by ROL Italian
    https://hinduunation.com/2012/07/04/1003/

    NOW
    INDIA is a BANANA REPUBLIC because ONLY WHITE SKINS AND THEIR SEWER SIDEPRDS know economy. Now we have 100% unemployment, economy worse than Zimbabwe, 100000 % inflation, ALL PEOPLE ARE begging on streets, their cars have been replaced by 2nd hand cycles begged from Bdesh, pakistan and Congo, we are in negative growth , ONLY ISLANDS OF ABOVE prosperity ARE ITALIAN QUEEN AND ITALIAN PIDI (Pigs and Dogs of Italian) RULED MP , RAJASTHAN, PANJAB whose economy taken in isolation is China Plus US combined and these states are actually powerhouses feeding entire world ITALIAN AND PIDID MIDAS TOUCH
    MODIJI AND AMIT SHAHJI PLEASE LEAVE ANY CORRUP AFTER ALL CORRUPT AND CORRUPTION ARE BY THE GROVELLING PIGSTY OF WHITE SKINNED ITALIAN AND AS PER PIDIS WHITE SKIN IS MOST HOLY ..WHY CHASE THEM PLEASE PAY ATTENTION TO ECONOMY BECAUSE IT FALTERS AS TOUCHING EVEN CHAMCHAS AND SLAVES OF HOLY WHITE SKIN ITALIAN BRINGS THE WRATH OF JEALOUS GOD ON WHOLE INDIA

    2. MODIJI DO NOT PROSECUTE THE PRO PAKISTANI, PRO TERROIRIST VATICAN AND ITALIAN STREETPIGS, AND BREAKING INDIA FORCES..WHY DO YOU WANT TO DO THAT..PAY ATTENTION TO ECONOMY OUCHING EVEN CHAMCHAS AND SLAVES OF HOLY WHITE SKIN ITALIAN BRINGS THE WRATH OF JEALOUS GOD ON WHOLE INDIA.ECONOMY WILL BOOM LIKE ANYTHING IN HEAVEN ONLY ITALIAN WHITE TOUCH IS REQUIRED
    3. HER EXCELLENCY MADAM QUEEN OF INDIA SHOULD BE YOUR GUIDING LIGHT, BECAUSE FOR PIDIS WHITE SKIN IS RIGHT SKIN please pay attention to economy and it will BOOM only when you become SLAVE MMS like PM, DO YOU BOTH LOWLY MODI AND AMIT SHAH BROWN SKIN DO NOT EVEN KNOW THAT
    YOU should know that eating even the imported White Italian pigshit should entitle you to RAPE, CORRUPTION, LOOT, PEDOPHILIA, CHILD RAPE, MURDER, VIOLENCE because U know LICKING the ass of even Dog of White specially ITALIAN washes all sins and bestows ALL Heaven to you brown, poor heathens, non English, blood No knowledge of BELOVED ROMAN ITALIAN

  3. HIS EXCELLENCY NaMo, Amit Shah, here is a humble request from a common man –

    Forget about Economy for some time, let it run as it is;
    Forget about Pakistan for a while, let them say whatever they want;
    Plea…………………………….se PUT OUR HOME IN ORDER, PUT OUR JUDICIARY IN ORDER !!!
    Plea…………………………….se Take up all political corruption case on EMERGENCY BASIS, MAKE NEW LAWS ON EMERGENCY BASIS TO HANDLE SUCH CASES, AND ALSO PRESCRIBING SPECIAL PUNISHMENTS TREATING THE OFFENCE AS TREASON AND MORE, HIRE/IMPORT JUDGES FROM SINGAPORE AND SUCH OTHER TRUTHFUL COUNTRIES TO RUN THE TRIAL – AND DELIVER JUDGEMENT ON ALL THESE CASES WITHIN A MAXIMUM PERIOD OF 6 MONTHS.
    This will cure so many ills in the country. If the Govt CONFISCATES THE LOOTED WEALTH OF ALL SUCH POLITICIANS –
    I AM SURE OUR ECONOMY WILL TAKE CARE OF ITSELF !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    WE SHOULD NOT SPEND EVEN ONE RUPEE OF TAX PAYERS’ MONEY ON THESE POLITICIANS, EITHER THEY ALL SHOULD BE EXECUTED, OR SENT TO RUSSIAN LABOUR CAMPS FOR 100 YEARS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  4. Who cares for precedents anymore in the judiciary?
    By the by, this may be seen in this context–a Leftist intellectual rooting for PC:

    “https://m.facebook.com/sankar.ray.7/posts/2555857967807544?src=email_notif

    “The media’s disinformation on the role of Indrani Mukerjea in Chidambaram case, evident from Kapil Sibal’s interview. “Indrani Mukerjea gave a statement saying that Mr Chidambaram had said that you help Karti and then Karti had asked for, say x, amount. She doesn’t say whether and how the x amount was given, if at all it was. She said that one Peter Mukerjea was there when the meeting was taking place, as well as some other people. Peter Mukerjea has not supported Indrani. So the best evidence of the CBI is the statement of a murder accused who says her daughter was her sister and she is being prosecuted for her murder. This is the best the CBI can produce and it is oral in nature. Can any court of law accept this as evidence? It is shocking” (https://asianage.com/opinion/interview-of-the-week/250819/persecution-not-prosecution.html).”

    • Sir is it a leftist and intellectual. We are playing on the parameters set by the MAFIA. Orgy Islanders, PAID BHADWAS, pretend to be left and shit from the mouth. As for intellectual, some 2 bit BA in some social science, humanities, arty farty, 2 bit journo, soft porn writer or a 8th failed duffer ad or bollywood illiterate fool does not become “intellectual”just by mouthing few words in English. Intellectuals are Drs, Engineers, Scientists, Technicians, Farmers, soldiers, Workers etc….who are crucial for human existence. Now these 2 bit journos, Bolly farts, duffer ad makers, etc..even if they are wiped out 1000 times per day, does it mean ANYTHING TO HUMANITY, they are worse than pigshit insects which atleast decomposes the filth. THESE PARASITES ARE WORSE THAN ANY FILTH DEVISED. Moreover for them DICTIONARY SEARCHING IS LIFE, for us English is just a incidental language for our engineering

  5. Sir, 3 Journos have been exposed to be in cahoots with P Chidambram, 2 women journos and one man (or inbetween)- NAMED SHUKAR SURNAME IS AKIN TO DOG IN HINDI, like SONIA G, and the women journo who was a call girl on PC behest to lay the CBI officers and ED officers , same journo who brought the CBI/ED report to PC bedroom. THEy NEED TO BE NAMED AND SHAMED..ALL THIS CRAP ABOUT WOMEN AND WIMMIN IS PLANTED ONLY TO PROTECT THESE TREACHEROUS, CRIMINAL ELITE. Some Butt or Vidhi sounding names??? Or 2 BHK import from United Snakes??

  6. OUR GREAT MAL=LORDS. SCI= SUPREME CHAMCHAS OF ITALIAN
    1. BOKA THAKUR SPENT 37 YEARS IN JAIL (3 TIMES THE LIFE IMPRISONMENT), AS A UNDERTRIAL AS A THEFT ACCUSED AND WAS ACTUALLY JUDGED INNOCENT, LOST ALL HIS PRIME LIFE IN JAIL BECAUSE HE DID NOT HAVE MONEY TO FATTEN THE THUG MAL-LORDS
    2. COL PUROHIT, SADHAVI PRAGYA, BRIGADIER CHATURVEDI ALL TRAPPED BY THE ITALIAN BESTIAL,UNCOUTH , UNCULTURED, ILLITERATE FOREIGN WHITE SKINNED NAZI PRD REPROBATE CONSPIRACY, WERE JAILED FOR 9 YEARS AND UNDERWENT SO MUCH TORTURE, WITHOUT THE CHARGESHEET BECAUSE THEY DID NOT HAVE MONEY TO FATTEN THE MAL-LORDS
    3. TEESTA SEETALWAD THE TRAITOR, KNOWN CIA-ISI AGENT (IN ANY OTHER COUNTRY IT WOULD BE A BULLET IN THEIR ASS LIKE HEADS) WAS GRANTED “BAIL OVER THE PHONE”BY THE SAME MAL-LORDS (FIRST EVER EXAMPLE IN THW WORLD) BECAUSE THE PAKISTANI 47 VERMIN SIBAL , FIXED THE COURTS AND MAL-LORDS (WITH MONEY AND WOMEN)”JUSTICE “MUKHERJEE” AND “JOSEPH”WITH SIBAL AND “TANKHA”ANOTHER PAKISTANI FILTH
    4 D.G VANZARA The brave IPS Officer, who was jailed for 8 years without Chargesheet by the same MAL LORDS and ITALIAN AND WHITE AS WORSHIPPING PAKIPANJABI, ITALIAN NAZI AND PIDI SHIT EATING SLAVES CONGIS, for the encounter of a TERRORIST (Maybe Sonia/ Bianca needed him as substitute Rajiv / Vadra as Italian non culture this is common)
    5. THE ANTI SIKH GENOCIDE CASE is still under hearing, in SUPREME COURT 37 years after the actual occurance, with many petitionars and even their sons/daughters having died. as MAL LORDS demand of children, women or boys and money may have been higher
    6. RAM MANDIR pending for 70 years
    7. ITALIAN SONIA, RAUL VINCI CONTINUE TO GET BAIL IN RECORD TIME..GUINNESS BOOK OF RECORD, BAIL GRANTED IN FLAT 6 MINS EVEN BEFORE THE PROSECUTION COULD SETTLE IN THE CHAIRS (Over the phone on promise of Lolita Express and Virgin Island accounts)

    • SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU PER SUPER SUPER !!
      DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU PER DUPER DUPER !!

  7. The Judge of Patna High Court who exposed the Corruption and exposed these Judges, spcially The son of Butcher, Firangi and RAPIST RANJAN GOGOI as how the JUDGES get huge cuts for fixing Judgements has been removed from listening to cases by the Cotorie of pedophile MAFIOSI BOUGHT Thugs
    WHY MOST OF THE JUDGES OF SCI BELONG TO ONLY 3 BSTRDIZED STATES, PAKISTANIS OF 47, BDESHIS OF BANGAL AND ME GUTTER CLEANING KERALITE XTIANS MOSTLY PORTUGUESE AND SYRIANS SCAVENGING PIGS AND TROJAN HORSES OF VATICAN, ITALY, CIA ??? ALL OF INDIA PAYS TAXES FOR SALARIES OF THESE DEPRAVED, mendacious clerks called Judges. There should be a qualifying exams. Collegium is BIGGEST MAFIA in the world

  8. The connections of these Thug, rapist Judges, Mafiosi controlled Judges with Drug Mafia, pedophile , Blue Film Mafia, child trafficking and organ harvesting, child killing Mafia should be investigated.
    There are rumors that most of these Judges are honey trapped, many by ISI AND ITALIAN NAZI SONIA PIGS , PAKIPANJABI COURT FIXERS, THee treacherous PAKIPANJABI PITVIPERS because of their White sourced unknown FDI, DNA (Biological law, it takes 7 generations to wash of the genetic programming, but inbetween because of the white ass worhipping whorism their genes are progressively demented).
    The FIRANGIS (ITALIAN BRITS AND including HYBRID Bastards, specailly PAKIPANJABIS THE sewer filth that was deliberatly spilled in India by evil barbarian White Brits to perpetuate their rule with fake Kaul Brahmins, another bstd community created in Brit brothels)
    SCI should be moved out of Delhi and clutches of these evil Pakipanjabi rascals COURT FIXERS (In fact PAKISTAN Is PAKIPANJABI HELL HOLE and they have NO RIGHT TO BE IN INDIA, they either get slaughtered or kicked to Pakistan, their wh..like women, can be sold by Pakis to Chinese as sexslaves , to earn foreign currency,who cares NRC should be dated 1940 now)
    BY THE WAY SIR, there are Lolita Express and Orgy, pedophile islands (Just like Epstein) being run by journos and Italian Nazi Conquistador (Inquisition) party = INC (I) – and its Chief White Supremaicist Satan Sonia in under names of media brothels, a Private sting on these Judges and Journos will reveal the filthy truth about them
    They are banking on the castration of Hindus, vide the VATICAN ITALIAN MAFIA CHURCH running dogs of media, mostly Xtians, with fale Hindu names. INDIA REQUIRES A FRENCH REVOLUTION LIKE BLOODSHED OF THESE FIRANGIS BY NATIVE INDIAN HINDUSTANIS

  9. To enlighten common citizens like me, the learned Judges should clarify :-
    1. Precedents of such judgement and /or
    2. The special circumstances that called
    for such judgement and /or
    3. The provisions of Law based on which
    such judgement was delivered and /or
    4. If the law is specific to person, degree,
    position, political affiliation, financial
    status

    • MAL-LORDS will never answer, Gogoi says that he has only 6 lakh Rs in his official account, but nobody keeps crores of loot in official accounts, its siphoned vide Hawala in TAX HAVENS, Rapist never says he has raped. Every rapist, pedophile, murderer, traitor, foreign agent , ISI agent, mass murderer, criminal will simply say he is a leftist secular and LIBERAL, AS IF laws should be separate for these vermin

  10. SUPREME COURT OF INDIA = SCI = SUPER CHAMCHAS OF ITALIAN, CLEANING THIS SYSTEM REQUIRES PUBLIC FORMING TRIBUNALS AGAINST JUDGES AND GIVING THEM DEATH SENTENCE. Anybody who has read GODFATHER by Mario Puzo, which is the realistic novel about the workings of Italian Mafia, knows that the Mafia buys Judges and Media first. THUGS, PEDOPHILES, RAPISTS AND MURDERER JUDGES, AS POINTED OUT BY Sandeep Deo ji on youtube video (indiaspeaksdaily.com), 23 SCI Judges were under investigation for murder of Bhatnagar, one of the accused turned approvar in a case of huge scam, involving Supreme Court Judges, one of the same Tarun Chatterji on last day before retirement ordered arrest of Amit Shah, in a quid pro quo to save his murderous ass, another U.C. Banerjee, another Bangali Bangladeshi Thug in a junked report said that Godra burning was self immolation (Bangali gutter filth from sewer of the world Bdesh, self immolation, why not they would have burned Bangad bstds 5900, now Courts have sentenced to death a ITALIAN NAZI PARTY Killer, but Banerjee is out).
    This Chief Justice is himself a Rape accused, a rapist. In addition he is the son of the Greatest Butcher of Indians in History of 20th century India, called keshab Chandra Gogoi, who butchered 12000 Assamese in the notorious 1983 elections imposed by ITALIAN SONIA AND INDIRA despite all opposition ready for constitutional amendment, JUST TO SAVE THE BDESHI GUTTER FILTH JIHADIS.
    Also this CJI DNA is infested with demonic white xtian DNA, This running dog of Vatican mother is a WHITE SKINNED RACIST Brit, his relative is Tarun Gogoi both whose so called Wife and DIL are white skinned racist, barbrians, Brit.His wife is a White skinned ITALIAN
    Till we Indians not respond in the way of French revolution (nothing to do with White Supremacist Klannist Conquistador Ruuning dogs , the Commies) against these FIRANGIS (including HARAMIS-WHITE SKIN EVIL INFESTED DNA) and seize power India will be a enslaved nation by these OUTSIDERS-WHITE SKINNED EVIL DEMONS RUNNING DOGS OF WESTERN XTIANITY, VATICAN AND ITALY..ITS A WAR BETWEEN HARAMIS AND HINDUSTANIS

  11. It is time that military style courts should be installed to probe economic offences, where bail should not be granted and judgement to be pronounced in 2 years as in US. Our British origin judicial system has become obsolete. Unless we have an efficient system, criminals will rule the nation.

    Why should SC take up suomoto rape cases selectively ? Why can’t they have a bench to handle suomoto , every rape case in India? Why can’t life imprisonment be given to women and activist advocates if false rape charges are levied with ulterior motive ?

  12. The nation has already concluded that the judiciary is occupied by the judges anointed by the mafia of scamgress and they too obviously are urban naxals to the taste of the said mafias. Granting two dozen bails, and succumbing for the culprit’s plea have become order of the day if the culprits are influenced bureaucrats, moneyed or political scoundrels. God alone should save the nation.

  13. As expected, SC is ever so eager to help out corrupt politicians in India. Any wonder that Judiciary is losing/has lost respect of common Indian public?

  14. These two Judges Banumati & Bopannah should be arrested without delay.

    There is no doubt a minimum of 100crore has changed hands for showing undue favors to Chidambaram by these two criminals in the uniform of Judges.

    It is an open Secret in the Judicial Circles BAILS are sold at anywhere between 5 to 50 crores.

    Kapil Sibbal, AMS, Chidambaram, Nalini Chidambaram & a host of their fraternity are nothing but DALALS between LITIGANTS & JUDGES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here