Home Ministry’s (MHA) contradicting stands in issue of Security Clearance
[dropcap color=”#008040″ boxed=”yes” boxed_radius=”8px” class=”” id=””]I[/dropcap]n a bizarre incident, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has filed two contradicting affidavits in Supreme Court and Delhi High Court regarding the issue of Security Clearance to media houses in running Radio/ TV channels. In what could be only be termed a highly dubious act in the Supreme Court (SC), on February the MHA diluted its stand on security clearance allotted to Sun TV Group’s FM Radio channels, excusing them because of hte the economic situation in the sector and toughened its stand in Delhi High Court in March on Haryana-based TV channel – STV. Interestingly both contradicting stands were filed by the same officer!
So Jaitley the FM was for prosecuting the Marans but not Jaitley the I & B Minister!
In the SC on SUN TV’s security clearance related case, in what can only be termed as protecting the Maran brothers, the MHA said that security clearance cannot be withheld if promoters of the company are facing prosecution. MHA further argued that the security clearance will be an issue if a court convicts a person!. In the past, in many cases, the MHA has rejected security clearance due to promoters facing prosecution by various agencies. Was this an instance of the Maran Money Power at play? Note that the Maran brothers are currently facing trial in illegal telephone exchange case. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED) had already filed appeals against the discharge of Maran brothers in the Aircel-Maxis case.
The Ministry was responding to a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by BJP leader Subramanian Swamy for creating a national policy on issuing security clearances to companies. Home Ministry filed the affidavit on February 21.
[dropcap color=”#008040″ boxed=”yes” boxed_radius=”8px” class=”” id=””]H[/dropcap]ome Ministry also informed the apex court that a recently formed Cabinet Secretariat headed body is the ultimate authority in issuing security clearances in consultation with the concerned Ministry and Finance Ministry. MHA’s powers were curtailed in September 2016, after the controversy on the Sun TV security clearance issue, after the promoters Maran brothers were charge sheeted in Aircel-Maxis and illegal telephone exchange cases. Though it objected first, MHA diluted its stand later. Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, who was also then I & B Minister even, wrote to Home Minister Rajnath Singh for allowing security clearance to Sun TV Group in FM Radio auction. The irony was that MHA was acting on the actions of Enforcement Directorate, which is also under Finance Ministry (FM). So Jaitley the FM was for prosecuting the Marans but not Jaitley the I & B Minister! In a previous article, PGurus had pointed out how similar conflicts can arise between Finance and Defence Departments.
The affidavit filed in the Delhi High Court by MHA shows the decisions on the issuing security clearances for the past decade, where the Intelligence Bureau Report was considered as the prime decision maker.
Swamy approached the apex court for the formulation of national policy after the contradicting judgments from different High Courts.
But within a month on March 29 in Delhi High Court, MHA took a tough stand on another TV channel’s security related issue. Opposing Haryana-based STV’s petition, MHA retained its authority in granting security clearance. In this case, none of the Directors of the company were facing cases and the only issue was that the promoters were related to controversial Haryana politician Gopal Kanda, who has been embroiled in many cases. Taking a U-turn from the Sun TV case, MHA said the Intelligence Bureau’s adverse reports are the ultimate in taking decisions on providing security clearances.
The affidavit filed in the Delhi High Court by MHA shows the decisions on the issuing security clearances for the past decade, where the Intelligence Bureau Report was considered as the prime decision maker. Only in the high profile Sun TV Group’s case, MHA has taken a diluted stand, arguing for the economic aspect in the sector. All channels are equal but some are more equal?!
In his rejoinder filed in Supreme Court, Subramanian Swamy argued that there should be a National Policy on the issue of security clearance and loopholes have resulted in contradicting judgments and lobbying in MHA in getting by corrupt persons security clearances.
Both contradicting affidavits of MHA are published below. Subramanian Swamy’s rejoinder to MHA’s dillydallying also published below.
1. Affidavit of MHA filed in Supreme Court favoring SUN TV Group’s security clearance on Feb 21, 2017.
MHA Affidavit on Security Clearnace in SC Feb 21, 2017 by PGurus on Scribd
2. Affidavit of MHA filed in Delhi High Court objecting STV’s security clearance on March 29, 2017.
MHA Affidavit on Security Clearance in Delhi HC March 29, 2017 by PGurus on Scribd
3. Subramanian Swamy’s rejoinder to MHA’s stand in Supreme Court on the issue of security clearances:
Rejoinder – Dr Swamy National Security by PGurus on Scribd
1. Text in Blue points to additional data on the topic.
- CBI books Rolls Royce of corruption in Hawk 115 Advanced Jet Trainer aircraft deal - May 29, 2023
- Jet Airways: NCLAT allows more time for Jalan Kalrock Consortium to make payments; rejects lenders’ plea for invoking guarantee - May 26, 2023
- NIA urges Delhi High Court, seeks death penalty for Kashmiri terrorist Yasin Malik - May 26, 2023
Home Ministry and Home Minister Rajnath Singh fall into the pressures put by Arun Jaitley for Maran brothers. Due to Spice Jet dubious return deal, Maran won over Jaitley and Delhi’s dealer-wheeler gangs. Rajnath Singh should have been stern. But not. Shame
Nice spin . This is the typical spin doctors version trying to put all the blame on Jaitley and trying to disown him from party. After all it shows the collective ineffectiveness,moral bankruptcy of BJP as a whole and more importantly exposes the so-called 56”.
Kishore, there is no spin when the proof is presented in the form of copies of the affidavits right below the article. Rebut with facts.
INC/Cong is way better in this aspect that they don’t show one face outside & another inside. BJP cannot talk anymore of sycophancy/high command nature of Cong/INC when its own house is ugly/dirty. Is Swamy still a exec member of ruling party/BJP or a dummy or worse a make-believe anti-corruption crusader havin 2 faces just like FM who is accused of here?
VERY TRUE, MORE THAN THIS SUN TV’s Red FM channels are/were in alliance with Astro Malaysia who are also in the courts for Aircel Maxis deal. so in all aspects, these Red FM Radio channels are to be banned