The story behind the denial of Cryogenic engine technology to India

USA was watching India’s progress in space research and was constantly gathering information about ISRO’s future plans

USA was watching India’s progress in space research and was constantly gathering information about ISRO’s future plans
USA was watching India’s progress in space research and was constantly gathering information about ISRO’s future plans

The long road to Cryogenic engine technology

25th December 1991, Moscow. The sickle hammer flag the Red flag was lowered, signalling the fall of the famous, mammoth, iron wall country the USSR – Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.

The USSR was weakened by the western world’s constant pressure to push USSR into democracy. Now the TRI colour Russian flag was hoisted reducing the power of the USSR to a minimum, and now the Russian country had come under the significant influence of the USA.

India was rapidly improving in the space research programme and on 18th January 1991, ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) entered into an agreement with Russian space agency Glavkosmos for the technology transfer of “Cryogenic engine” which powers heavy rockets with cheaper fuel cost.

USA was watching India’s progress in space research and was constantly gathering information about ISRO’s future plans. India which had already developed a ballistic missile ‘AGNI’ and the USA was suspecting that the technology transfer of the Cryogenic engine will power up India and could become a superpower in rocket and satellite launching programme.

India is the only developing country with heavy lift ambitions and its ultra-low-cost model could one day put the likes of NASA out of business. That’s an eventuality that the United States wants to delay India’s space programme as long as it can.

It is time to know about the Cryogenic engine

I will try to explain it in very simple common man terms.

To lift a rocket and fly, they use various types of fuel (similar to petrol we use to run a motor car). India has been using solid propellent fuel which needs a heavy fuel tank and needs huge quantity of fuel, which would not only push the cost high but also restrict the travel distance.

India was constantly on the lookout for fuel that can be light in weight and energy efficient. The Cryogenic engine was the only answer.

In that, the hydrogen and oxygen would be used in liquid form at high pressure which can fuel the lift of heavy rockets and also be fuel efficient.

Author and broadcaster Brian Harvey write in his exhaustively researched book ‘Russia in Space: The Failed Frontier’ that in the late 1980s India was looking to develop a massive rocket to launch satellites into 24-hour orbit. India first talked to Japan but nothing came off it. Hearing of these overtures, the Indians were approached first by General Dynamics Corporation, which offered an American engine. But the cost was prohibitive as was an offer shortly thereafter from Europe’s Arianespace.

“Just then a third approach came, this time from the Soviet Union, offering two engines and technology transfer for the more reasonable price of $200 million,” writes Harvey.

The Russians were offering a secret engine, the RD-56 or KVD-1, built by the Isayev Design Bureau. The KVD-1 had unsurpassed thrust and capabilities and NASA had nothing that could match the Russian engine for years. In fact, the rocket engine was originally developed as part of the Soviet manned moon landing programme as far back as 1964.

On 18th January 1991, ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) entered into an agreement with Russian space agency Glavkosmos for the technology transfer of the “Cryogenic engine”

ISRO and Glovkosmos suspected that the USA would object to this technology transfer under the Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR) – a Western cabal that aims to deny ballistic missile technology to non-Western countries, especially India.

And hence ISRO and Glovkosmos were ready with Plan B. According to this Glovkosmos would outsource the manufacturing of its Cryogenic engine to Kerala Hi-tech Industries Limited (KELTEC) so that the technology would be available to India by this arrangement.

Aleksey Vasin, officer-in-charge of Cryogenic technology in Glavkosmos, and ISRO Chairman U R Rao – believed that if Russian Cryogenic technology was passed on to ISRO via KELTEC, technically it would not be a violation of the MTCR.

As expected in May 1992, the USA slapped sanctions on ISRO and Glovkosmos alleging that the arrangement is in violation of MTCR.

India also pointed out the Americans had offered them the very same technology and had made no objections throughout the years 1988-92 when the arrangements had begun.

So does that mean the Americans were trying to achieve the dual aim of crippling both the Indian and Russian space programmes? It was too obvious.

India and Russia said that the Cryogenic engine technology was being used purely for scientific purposes and not to be used in the missile and they invited MTCR to inspect the technology arrangements.

Former US President Bill Clinton and his hawkish wife Hillary Rodham Clinton are for some inexplicable reason considered friends of India. It was under President Clinton that Russia backed off its proposals to transfer technology to India and suspended its agreement, invoking force majeure (circumstances beyond its control).

Under the revised Russia-India agreement in January 1994, Moscow agreed to transfer three, later renegotiated by India to seven fully assembled KVD-1 engines, without the associated technology. The United States also inserted a humiliating clause, according to which India would “agree to use the equipment purely for peaceful purposes, not to re-export it or modernize it without Russia’s consent”. No blueprints were to be given to India.

But the Glovkomos scientist developed some liking for ISRO scientists and they have decided to help Indian scientists.

If you read the following, I am sure you will feel like seeing a spy thriller movie.

However, with American spies crawling all over Russia during the early 1990s, transferring such a large cargo wasn’t going to be easy. “ISRO first contacted Air India but the airline said it could not transport the equipment without customs clearance. And that was not possible without the American lobby in Russia coming to know about it,” J Rajasekharan Nair reveals in his book, Spies From Space: The ISRO Frame-Up[1].

So ISRO entered into an agreement with Russia’s Ural Airlines, which was ready to take the risk for a little extra money. Author and broadcaster Brian Harvey writes in his exhaustively researched book ‘Russia in Space: The Failed Frontier.’ According to Harvey, “The appropriate documents, instruments, and equipment were allegedly transferred in four shipments from Moscow to Delhi on covert flights by Ural Airlines. As a cover, they used ‘legitimate’ transhipments of Indian aircraft technology travelling the other way to Moscow for testing in Russian wind-tunnels.”

This was confirmed by Cryogenic team leader Nambi Narayanan who told the Indian media he was on board the flights that transported the technology to India.

By this time USA had realized that further arm twisting would not do any good and decided to try other means to scuttle the space programme of India, as it would be a direct threat to NASA’s business opportunity.

Nambi Narayanan by now had become a household name, who was interviewed by almost all international, national, and regional TV channels and other media was in charge of Cryogenic engine technology and his deputy Sasi Kumaran.

The CIA was entrusted with the work of aborting India’s ISRO’s Cryogenic engine dream.

Nambi Narayanan being an important cog in the wheel was arrested and tortured by the Kerala police and the IB. Nambi Narayanan was alleged to have sold important military information through 2 Maldivian women he had never met at all.

The first hint there was a foreign hand trying to destroy – or at the very least slow down – India’s space programme surfaced in 1997 when five leading scientists – Satish Dhawan, U R Rao, Yashpal, Rodham Narasimha, and K Chandrasekhar – along with former Chief Election Commissioner T N Seshan wrote a joint letter to the government, saying the espionage charges against Nambi Narayanan and Sasi Kumaran were fabricated.

These were not ordinary people – they were public figures who clearly knew a thing or two about the inner workings of ISRO and the law and order system. And yet despite their plea, the IB tortured Nambi Narayanan to get him to implicate higher-ups at ISRO. If Narayanan had cracked and acquiesced, perhaps the entire organization would have collapsed.

It is a measure of how successful the CIA was in this spy game that its agents in the Kerala police and Intelligence Bureau (IB) were able to have a swing at just about everyone in the Cryogenic project, writes Rajasekaran Nair, in his book ‘The book Spies from Space: The Isro Frame-up.’

By removing the important man from the project the USA successfully scuttled the dream of ISRO and India.

The truth cannot be hidden for a long time. The case was transferred to CBI. Further investigation proved that Nambi Naryanan and Sasi Kumaran were not involved in any anti-national activity and they were acquitted and received monetary compensation for the custodial hardship and social humiliation they went through.

For ISRO and India, it became a challenge to develop Cryogenic engine indigenously as the popular saying goes “Necessity is the mother of invention.”

Accordingly, ISRO successfully developed the Cryogenic engine and started the space business by launching several GSLV rockets and putting India and several other countries’ satellites into orbit at a fraction of NASA’s cost, which is what the USA was fearing.

India also sent a vehicle to Mars at one-fourth cost and that too in its maiden attempt compared to USA’s several attempts.

India’s ISRO now has emerged as one of the world’s largest space organization after meeting tough challenges – Sathyameva Jayathe. Jai Hind.

Note:
1. Text in Blue points to additional data on the topic.
2. The views expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of PGurus.

Reference:

[1] Why My Book Didn’t SellJan 25, 2013, Open the Magazine

PGurus is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with all the latest news and views

For all the latest updates, download PGurus App.

Paranji Kuppuswamy Sowmyanarayanan.( P.K. Sowmynarayanan)
Born and brought up in Chennai
*Studied SSLC in St.Gabriels High School, Broadway, George Town)
*Did PUC in Kandasamy Naidu College of Arts and Science,Anna Nagar.
*Graduated in Science Degree from Nandanam Arts College, Madras University.
* Obtained a Post graduate Diplomo in Construction Management, from Madras Productivity Council,
*Trained in Law from Madurai Kamarajar University.
*Did Computer application course in Computer Point .
*Joined as Junior Inspector in Department of Cooperation ,
Govt of Tamilnadu after passing out Group 3 examination .
*Passed Diplomo in Cooperation in record time of 3 months. *Promoted as Senior Inspector within short period of 1 year. Served in the department for 4 years .
*Resigned after witnessing high level of corruption and switched to private Sector, Real Estate Business.
*Served for about 40 years in Real Estate Industry.
*Retired as Senior Vice President & Director from one of theleading Real Estate Group
XS Real Group.
*Now pursuing my passion of Book writing.
P.K. Sowmynarayanan
Latest posts by P.K. Sowmynarayanan (see all)

8 COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here