Delhi High Court dismisses Sonia-Rahul Gandhi petitions against Income Tax re-assessing in National Herald case

Another delay tactic quashed. Sonia and Rahul must wonder if PC is their best option to represent them when he himself is running from court to court on his scams

Another delay tactic quashed. Sonia and Rahul must wonder if PC is their best option to represent them when he himself is running from court to court on his scams
Sonia and Rahul must wonder if PC is their best option to represent them when he himself is running from court to court on his scams

Time has started ticking for Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi in the National Herald case. Delhi High Court on Monday dismissed the pleas of Congress leaders Sonia Gandhi,  Rahul Gandhi and Oscar Fernandes challenging reopening of their tax assessments for 2011-12. The Income Tax issued orders to re-assess the tax returns, after finding that the Congress leaders did not reveal their directorship in the firm Young Indian, which took over the National Herald newspaper publishing firm Associated Journals Limited (AJL).  Dismissing the petitions, the Bench comprising Justices S Ravindra Bhat and A K Chawla said that Income Tax has right to issue such orders and directed the petitioners to approach the appropriate forum, if aggrieved by the Income Tax’s order.

Sonia Gandhi was represented by the former Finance Minister and senior lawyer P Chidambaram and Rahul Gandhi was represented by noted tax lawyer Arvind Datar. Many Congress leaders feel that Chidambaram had gossiped against Kapil Sibal and Abhishek Singhvi and got them removed from the National Herald cases.

The High Court has already rejected the Congress leaders’ demand for restraining media houses from publishing the news related to Income Tax process in the National Herald cases. It is an irony that Chidambaram who nowadays speaks too much on freedom of expression argued for media banning in National Herald case.

The Income Tax Department, in December 2017, fined Young Indian for Rs.250 crores for suppressing the taxable income of Rs.414 crores in 2011-2012. PGurus has already detailed the Income Tax Order on this matter[1]. After this Income Tax issued orders in March 2018 for re-assessing the income of the leaders as they had suppressed their directorship in Young Indian.

The Young Indian was floated on December 2010 and the scam got exposed only when Subramanian Swamy exposed the matter on November 1, 2012. This shows that Sonia and Rahul kept the directorship and floating of Young Indian as a secret and hence did not declare to Income Tax in 2011 & 2012 March Income Tax Returns.

The High Court had on August 16 reserved its order on the pleas of the three leaders after the Income Tax Department had contended that Rahul Gandhi’s tax assessment for 2011-12 was reopened as material facts were concealed. The bench had orally asked the tax department not to take any coercive step against Sonia, Rahul, and Fernandes till pronouncement of its verdict.

Appearing for Income Tax Department, Additional Solicitor General Tushar Mehta had argued that the Congress leaders had alleged mala fide on the part of the tax department but had not made any averments in this regard. Congress leaders accused Income Tax of “coercing” and acting on the complaints of the BJP leader Subramanian Swamy.

The Income Tax also found that Congress claim of giving Rs.90 crores to AJL was bogus and this was bogus claim was floated to acquire the assets of AJL, which is more than Rs.5000 crores land assets across the country.  The tax department had said the shares Rahul has in Young Indian would lead him to have an income of Rs.154 crores and not about Rs.68 lakhs, as assessed earlier.

Meanwhile, Subramanian Swamy’s submission of evidence is going on in the trial court and the next hearing is posted for September 17. After this, he will be cross-examined by a battery of Congress lawyers.

References:

[1] National Herald case: Read 105-page Income Tax Assessment Order against Young Indian exposing Rs.414 crores gainJan 22, 2018, PGurus.com

Team PGurus

We are a team of focused individuals with expertise in at least one of the following fields viz. Journalism, Technology, Economics, Politics, Sports & Business. We are factual, accurate and unbiased.

13 COMMENTS

  1. Simultaneously crook P C also should be nailed in Aircel Maxis case.But before that and to ensure that the 3 serving IAS rogues(Ashok Chawla etc.)stonewalling proceedings against PC should be prosecuted.Let us send a petition to PM.

    E S Jayaraman

    • Yes. For a start, we should submit a ‘petition.’ But it should be followed by ‘Token Relay Fast’ (1 day) & ‘indefinite Fast’. I am prepared to sit on ‘indefinite Fast’ – if the ‘petition’ & the ‘1-day relay Fast’ do not work. Can someone take the initiative & organize this. Petition should be drafted first. Anybody willing to organize please come forward. (Message from Nagar Narayanan Gosevak Gopal Goshala Karjat)

  2. Simultaneously crook P C also should be nailed in Aircel Maxis case.But before that and to ensure that the 3 serving IAS rogues(Ashok Chawla etc.)stonewalling proceedings against PC should be prosecuted.Let us send a petition to PM.

    E S Jayaraman

  3. PC’s presence in the court superceding Abhishek Singvi and Kapil is motivated. Is it an attempt to pressurise the court? WILL NOT the presence of an influential and high profile exFM( for 10 years) intimidate the court?

    • Yes Ganesh. There’s a high probability. Chidambaram is the most unscrupulous & sordid crook of the current political leaders. He has planted his moles in all institutions fully aware UPA will be voted out in 2014. We can expect he will be negotiating a favorable Judgement instead of argument

  4. Tihar is a luxury for these political crooks !! don’t we have any provision to send the Political Crooks to the Russian Labour Camps or to the Guantanamo-like outfits outside India ?!

    Until we start sending the Crook Political Lawyers to Labour Camps, they will keep arguing and prolonging all political cases until the accuseds die, like in JJ case.

    SS vindicated, but the culprits go unpunished.

    • Tihar is a luxury for these political crooks !! don’t we have any provision to send the Political Crooks to the Russian Labour Camps or to the Guantanamo-like outfits outside India ?!

      Until we start sending the Crook Political Lawyers to Labour Camps, they will keep arguing and prolonging all political cases until the accuseds die, like in JJ case.

      SS vindicated, but the culprits go unpunished.

  5. Congratulations to Dr.Swamy for his untiring work in National Herald case expose. The credit also goes to Patriotic Bold officers in Income Tax

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here