Tamil Nadu temple lands – Govt apathy or pandering?

An instance of the Tamil Nadu HR & CE mismanaging the temples and other charitable establishments

An instance of the Tamil Nadu HR & CE mismanaging the temples and other charitable establishments
An instance of the Tamil Nadu HR & CE mismanaging the temples and other charitable establishments

The Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR & CE) Department of Tamil Nadu was formed in 1960. Prior to that, under the British rule, the then Madras Presidency had passed the Madras Hindu Religious Endowments Act in 1923. I want to clearly establish the fact that this was, is and will remain a Hindu Religion related establishment.

This story that I am about to relate goes back over a hundred and twenty years! A land supposedly gifted (Inam) by the kings centuries ago to the Madurai Meenakshi Sundareswarar Devasthanam (MSD), changed hands from a Madurai temple priest (Bhattars) to some Chettiars and then from them to the Roman Catholic Mission of St. Mary’s Church (RCM) in 1894. The problem was that the land never belonged to the Bhattars – The Inam Register of 1863 clearly states the names of two Bhattars as the athakinama of Pagoda Meenakshi Sundershwarar and the inam is described as Devadayam for the archakal service, i. e. God’s income for the services rendered. This is quoted in the Supreme Court judgment.

I must clarify the word athakinama – this is mis-spelt as there is no such word in Sanskrit. It refers to either Athyathykama (Perpetual beneficiary) or atheenamaga (as ownership) of the temple. One may argue that this was deep in Tamil Nadu and question the usage of a Sanskrit word – but there are several stone inscriptions that state that in legal decrees, Sanskrit words were used.

Back to the Bhattars, the priest family. It was their responsibility to till the land and pay the temple and keep a portion for their efforts. They never owned it and hence the sale to the Chettiars was illegal. This 49 acres of land belonging to Madurai Temple, is now located in the center of Madurai and is worth Rs.600 crores. And despite a Supreme Court verdict granting it to the MSD, the RCM continues to occupy it. And the then HR & CE ministry in the first Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) is responsible. It is under their watch that a Tehsildar wrote that RCM is the right beneficiary, quoting the 1894 purchase! Contempt of Court? In my book (and I am sure many of the readers will agree) it is Contempt of Court of an order passed by a Constitutional Bench. The 19-page judgment can be found at the end of this post. It is stunning that the DMK government did not approach the Supreme Court and get back the rights to this prime property.

The saga of this story is illustrated in Figure 1 below:

Figure 1. How HR & CE bungled and lost Temple land
Figure 1. How HR & CE bungled and lost Temple land

From reading the Supreme Court (SC) judgment, it is clear that the bench, headed by M Hidayatullah had diligently gone through all the judgments. It is interesting to read what the  SC had to say about the Madras High Court ruling (page 17):

The next question which was considered by the High Court as whether resuming and regranting the inam to a Hindu temple, offended the Constitution. The High Court did not accept this submission. It is obvious that by the transfer of the inam the temple was deprived of a benefit and the transferee had no right to hold that benefit. What was done was to restore to the temple what it had lost and this was not putting a denominational religious institution at an advantage.

The transferee in the above paragraph refers to the RCM (the Church).

What is the mischief here?

Why did the Inams Settlement Tehsildar overrule the Supreme Court judgment? A section of this report where he is citing the 1894 purchase by RCM and thereby giving it back to them is shown below in Figure 2. Did the concerned tehsildar, K A Karuppaiah, exceed his brief?

Figure 2. Tehsildar's dubious decision
Figure 2. Tehsildar’s dubious decision

More importantly, what was the HR & CE department doing? Here was a prime piece of real estate in the town of Madurai, worth several crores and they just looked the other way! DMK has some explaining to do.

How did this come to light?

That some concerned citizens never gave up fighting for what they believed was temple land is obvious. A concerned individual decided to find out in 2013 the root cause of this dispute and filed a Right To Information (RTI) which unearthed these details and one other unfortunate fact – In 1982, the then Tamil Nadu government under M G Ramachandran gave the patta to RCM and then fixed Rs.8406.24 per fasal (harvest)! And that amount was not paid by the Tamil Nadu government to the temple! For a 49-acre land, a paltry amount of Rs.8406 was being charged and even that the Tamil Nadu government did not pay. The RTI goes on to state that efforts are being made to collect this amount.

This is just one instance of injustice meted out to a temple. There are many more. The current government can start cleaning house by making this right. Do it now.

Copy of the Supreme Court judgment:

The Roman Catholic Mission … by on Scribd

Follow me

Sree Iyer

An inventor and out-of-the-box thinker, Sree Iyer has 37 patents in the areas of Hardware, Software, Encryption and Systems.

His first book NDTV Frauds has been published and is an Amazon Bestseller.It ranked second among all eBooks that were self-published in 2017.

His second book, The Gist of GSTN which too is available on Amazon as an e-Book and as a paperback.

His third book, The Rise and Fall of AAP is also available in print version or as an e-Book on Amazon.

His fourth book, C-Company just released to rave reviews and can be bought as a print version or as an e-Book on Amazon.
Follow me

7 COMMENTS

  1. Check out Shree TV in you tube for all the atrocities HRCE have been doing.
    People can’t be fooled always.
    Those Brahmins who support DMK will lose all their previous punniyam….
    No Brahmin should do any puja for them …
    A group which was responsible for the destruction of Hindu fabric and temples should not be helped… A group which was responsible for defaming Brahmins (I am not a brahmin but a maravar ) and their rituals should come begging to them to help and yet be mercilessly declined help, for safeguarding Hinduism.
    Bheshma n drona were destroyed because they stood with adharma…

  2. Mr. M. K. Stalin Should Sincerely Seek the Inputs of Durga Devi and restore the property to the MSD. He would win the votes of all Hindus and redress the sins committed so far. If this is not done, Brother Alagiri would compete to take over and steal the show. Chance given for brothers to unite and do some good for Madurai Meenakshi Temple. Brothers to come out from the garb of pseudo-atheistic drama they have been enacting to fool Tamilnadu simpletons. Like Rahul Gandhi let DMK and AIADMK fight to work for the welfare of Hindus and the Madurai Meenakshi Temple to survive.

    • How can you say such things ..
      God gives time but when you fail, things go out of hands.
      DMK will have to suffer no matter what…
      They were stupid and in order to be in power helped the abrahamic religions to establish in tamilnadu and no durga can save them.
      God doesn’t need their help… And their destruction will be done.
      Communists, congress n DMK enemies of Hindu temples.

  3. An acre is about 44000 acres. 49 acres would be about 900 grounds. Therefore this piece of land in the middle of Madurai City is easily worth Rs.3000 crores. Mind boggling treachery by DMK & ADMK governments to Sri Meenakshi Sundareswarar Temple. Thanks Sree Iyer for exposing a misdeed that was hidden from Hindus for 50 years

  4. I knew something was wrong…
    Meenakshi Amman is left to suffocate by the churches surrounding it. Four directions blocked by churches..
    DMK will pay the price… JJ was a temporary enemy to keep them away from power. Gods will have their vengeance…
    Can anyone hope to build a big temple near Velankanni (again this itself was built on a Hindu temple) ….
    But around Meenakshi Amman temple they have built churches all along…
    All Hindus unitedly should stand against this atrocity… Meenakshi Amman temple has been there from centuries and those lands have been under the control of temple… Then how come so many churches and christian schools (UC school, St.mary school crop up) — if it was British who gave temple lands to missionaries then their lands will go under sea. Else whoever gave will see their end.
    Why no newspaper bothered to report all these all these years… Do they think missionaries are above Hindu gods…?
    It was the duty of every hindu, every social media to bring out all these scams ….
    HRCE should quit temples and temple lands …

  5. Only in India, A dispute case of Hindu Temples land abducted by Christians was fought in a secular court by a Muslim Judge and a so called pseudo secular atheist party doesnt appeal it.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here